Joseph McCann: Serial rapist ‘should never have been free to commit his crimes’

Serial rapist Joseph McCann should never have been free to commit his crimes in the first place, according to the former head of the Parole Board.

McCann subjected 11 victims to a horrifying ordeal in a spree of abductions across London and the North West.

Like the London Bridge terrorist Usman Khan, the 34-year-old was on an indeterminate sentence for previous violent offences.

Indeterminate sentences for public protection (IPPs) effectively carry a life licence, requiring a Parole Board assessment before an IPP prisoner is eligible for release.

McCann was released on licence in 2017, which meant he could be sent back to jail if he reoffended or breached his parole conditions.

Later that year, while on licence, he was arrested and charged with a further offence and was given a three-year jail term.

McCann’s case should have been referred to the Parole Board before he was released but in February this year he was dealt with as a “determinate sentence” prisoner.

This meant he was automatically released 18 months into his sentence.

It is understood one Probation Service worker was demoted as a result of a review of four staff who had direct contact with McCann.

Jo Farrar, the chief executive of HM Prisons and Probation Service, has “apologised unreservedly” for failings which led to McCann’s release two months before he launched his spree of sex attacks.

She said: “These were appalling crimes and our thoughts and sympathies are with the victims and their families.

“We recognise that there were failings and we apologise unreservedly for our part in this. We are committed to doing everything we possibly can to learn from this terrible case.

“We have taken strong and immediate action against those involved in the management of McCann’s case and are taking significant steps to improve intelligence sharing between agencies.

“At the same time, we are developing new mandatory training on recall for all probation officers and we have updated guidance on the threshold for recalling an offender to prison.”

Nick Hardwick, former chair of the Parole Board for England and Wales, had earlier told Sky News he was in no doubt mistakes were made in the handling of McCann’s release.

He said: “This is a very concerning case. It was a dreadful set of offences.

“In this case, there was clearly an individual error. McCann should have been referred to the Parole Board after he committed further offences and I’m very confident in those circumstances that the Parole Board would not have re-released him.

“The new offences were too similar to the previous ones, he wouldn’t have been re-released.”

Mr Hardwick, who is also a former chief inspector of prisons, said the issue highlights the worrying deterioration of the criminal justice system over recent years.

He said: “I think this is a symptom of a probation system and a court system under huge pressure, which makes individual mistakes more likely.

“It’s not that we need tough justice, we need smart justice. We need a whole system approach to tackling this. These are areas that have been neglected by the politicians and now we’re reaping the consequences of that.

“The problem with prison and probation is the number of experienced staff that we’ve lost. Even if you recruit new staff now, which they’re doing, they simply don’t have the experience of the people they are replacing and that’s what creates the dangers.”

There are differences between the apparent mix-up that led to McCann’s release and the automatic release of terrorist Khan.

But the fundamentals are essentially the same, two highly dangerous individuals released back into society without proper risk assessment from the Parole Board.

Mr Hardwick said: “Both of these cases reveal very worrying weaknesses in the prison and probation system, where very experienced commentators have said recently, these are systems in chaos.”

The Ministry of Justice launched an urgent review of the McCann case last spring.

Its findings have been on hold until the conclusion of McCann’s trial.

A source told Sky News that there were “missed opportunities” and that “lessons have been learned”.

The revelation that the 34-year-old rapist might never have been free to commit his offences in the first place, had vetting systems worked properly, will be of huge concern to McCann’s victims, who suffered life-altering trauma at his hands.

Mr Hardwick said he feared that a creaking criminal justice system might result in other cases falling through the cracks and that he was aware of a number of recent “near-misses”.

He said: “We need to look at the system failures here.

“Not just the individual error, but the circumstances that lay behind that. I think we’re more likely to correct those, if we don’t use it as another opportunity to score party political points, but we actually see this as an opportunity to try to get the system right, not simply win votes in the short term.”

(c) Sky News 2019: Joseph McCann: Serial rapist ‘should never have been free to commit his crimes’